Local weather at weather.gov

Trucking News · Nationwide ·

AI-Only Dash Cams May Miss Risky Driving They Record, and Fleets Can Still Be Held Responsible for It

A small dash camera mounted high on the windshield of a semi truck cab with a highway stretching ahead at dusk
Illustration for this story. Not a photo of a specific location.

Dash cameras that rely only on artificial intelligence to flag risky driving may be missing some of what they record, and a trucking defense attorney says fleets can be held responsible for that footage anyway.

A show of hands

The warning came at the American Trucking Associations' Management Conference and Exhibition in Charlotte, North Carolina, FreightWaves reported.

Sean Ritchie, a vice president at Solera Fleet Solutions, opened a panel by asking who in the room used dash cams. Every hand went up. He then asked people to keep their hands up if they knew their camera system's false-positive rate, how often the AI flags something that is not really there. A few hands dropped.

Then he asked who knew the false-negative rate, how often the AI misses risky driving that is on the video. Every hand went down.

Solera sells video safety systems that add human review, a point worth keeping in mind. Ritchie said Solera's analysis found up to 30% of AI-triggered videos held other risk the AI did not flag. FreightWaves noted the company has not published the sample size or method behind that figure.

Why misses matter

Doug Marcello, a trucking defense attorney and shareholder at Saxton and Stump, said fleets should treat any footage they keep as something that can come out in a lawsuit.

"If you have the activity of the driver captured by the video, you're going to be responsible for it," Marcello said. "And the defense or being able to say, wait, well, AI didn't pick it up is not going to be the response. It's not going to be an excuse."

He said uncoached risky driving on video can be used to argue a company has a weak safety culture.

How it happens

Ritchie said many AI-only systems send flagged clips straight to a fleet's coaching workflow with no human review. When vendors heard complaints about too many false alerts, some turned down the sensitivity, which can let more real risk slip through unlabeled. Drowsy driving was the most common miss, he said. Big Rig Daily has also covered how Motive's AI agents can act on fleet alerts on their own.

Safety teams are often small, and many coach only the risk the system labels, Ritchie said.

What the rules say

Federal rules allow safety technology on the windshield no more than 8.5 inches below the top of the area swept by the wipers. Nothing in them covers how the video has to be reviewed. With no standard, Marcello said, juries will set one.

Quick facts

A question for readers

Does the camera in the cab feel like protection, or like being watched?

Save this story for later

A small dash camera mounted high on the windshield of a semi truck cab with a highway stretching ahead at dusk

Sources