Truckers Say No to Off-Duty Random Drug Test Calls, as 82% of Nearly 400 Poll Voters Back a Petition to FMCSA

Most truckers who answered a recent reader poll do not want to be called in for a random drug test on their days off. In a poll of nearly 400 readers, 82% agreed with trucker Nathan Weidert's petition asking the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) to stop the practice, Overdrive reported on Nov. 20, 2026.
Get Big Rig Daily every morning
The trucking stories drivers are talking about, in one short email. Unsubscribe any time.
After you sign up, check your inbox for an email from news@bigrigdaily.com and tap the button to confirm.
Quick answer
Nathan Weidert has petitioned FMCSA to stop employers from notifying commercial driver's license (CDL) holders of random drug tests while they are off duty. He asks that random drug testing work more like alcohol testing, which can only happen just before, during or just after safety-sensitive work. Under current rules, a driver who is notified of a random drug test must go to a collection site immediately. In Overdrive's reader poll of nearly 400 people, 82% agreed with the petition.
Key facts
- Poll: nearly 400 Overdrive readers, 82% in favor of the petition's aims
- Petition: asks FMCSA to treat random drug test notifications more like alcohol testing
- Current rule: after notification, all of a driver's actions must lead to an immediate specimen collection
- Weidert's case: a former employer sent him to a clinic that was closed, then reported a refusal to test, which FMCSA later struck from his record
How a closed clinic led to a petition
Weidert's petition grew out of a notification from a company he no longer worked for. According to Overdrive, he tried to take the test at first. The company sent him to a clinic that was closed, then reported a refusal to test to FMCSA's Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse. Because he was working for a different company when he was selected, FMCSA has since struck the refusal from his Clearinghouse record. Big Rig Daily covered his petition to FMCSA in October, and the database itself is explained in Big Rig Daily's Clearinghouse guide.
Get Big Rig Daily every morning
The trucking stories drivers are talking about, in one short email. Unsubscribe any time.
After you sign up, check your inbox for an email from news@bigrigdaily.com and tap the button to confirm.
What readers told the poll
Many voters said off-duty time should stay off duty. "The company wants a random, then do it on their time, not mine!" one reader wrote. Another said he was called in while painting his house and had to clean everything up and go.
Driving to a collection site, waiting and giving a sample all count as on-duty time. Several commenters said an off-duty call had broken up a 34-hour restart more than once.
Not everyone agreed. A manager of a pool of owner-operators said many would rather test while at home than look for truck parking near a clinic in an unfamiliar area. One owner-operator said that, in his experience, off-duty screenings have been handled at a reasonable pace, about 48 hours, and that the current system still works.
What FMCSA guidance says now
FMCSA guidance quoted by Overdrive says that if an employer notifies a driver of a random test while the driver is off duty, the employer must make sure the driver proceeds immediately to a collection site. An employer that does not want to notify drivers while they are off duty can set the name aside until the driver returns to work, as long as that happens before the next random selection.
Should a company be able to call someone in for a random drug test on a day off?
Save this story for later

Sources
Get Big Rig Daily every morning
The trucking stories drivers are talking about, in one short email. Unsubscribe any time.
After you sign up, check your inbox for an email from news@bigrigdaily.com and tap the button to confirm.





